Strategic Partnership Education

Partner Evaluation Checklist

Seven groups of questions to answer before you commit to a strategic partner, referral source or vendor. Print it, bring it to the conversation, and score each group as strong, acceptable or weak.

Published November 1, 2026 ยท By Nexus Partnership Group LLC

How to use this checklist

Before the first meeting, write one sentence describing what you want this relationship to produce. Then work through the seven groups below during and after your conversations. Mark each item as confirmed, unclear or a concern. When you finish, score each group as strong, acceptable or weak.

A partner does not need to be strong in every group. Decline a partner who is weak in incentives, terms or compliance, no matter how strong the fit. Use the same checklist for every candidate so you are comparing like with like.

This page is formatted to print cleanly on letter-size paper. Use your browser's print function.

Fit

  • Their typical customer overlaps with ours enough that introductions will happen
  • The overlap is not so complete that we are direct competitors with the same buyers
  • They have worked in our industry or an adjacent one
  • They work with companies of roughly our size and stage
  • They can describe, in one sentence, what we do and who we serve
  • They can describe a company like ours that they would turn down, and why
  • Their goal for the relationship, in their words, is compatible with ours
  • No conflict with an existing partner of ours, or a conflict both existing partners accept

Capacity

  • A named person on their side will own the relationship day to day
  • That person's manager or a second contact is also identified
  • They can describe how many similar relationships they are managing now
  • They can explain their method as if to a new hire: how they identify, approach and hand off
  • They have the staff and time to meet the obligations under discussion
  • They have done this kind of arrangement before, and can describe one that went well and one that did not

Reputation

  • The legal entity is registered and active with the Secretary of State in its home state (in Texas, confirmed through SOSPortal)
  • The name on the proposal matches the name on the state record
  • Two or three direct references provided, including at least one former client or partner
  • References called, and asked what went wrong as well as what went right
  • The story they tell us matches what the references say and what the draft agreement says
  • Public materials, if any, are consistent with the conversations
  • Website testimonials and online reviews treated as leads to verify, not as evidence
  • No unresolved public disputes, judgments or regulatory actions found in a basic search

Incentives

  • How they are paid in this relationship is stated plainly: retainer, fee, commission, reciprocal, or none
  • Whether anyone other than us pays them in connection with this work, and who
  • Any referral fee, commission or revenue share they receive from third parties they introduce us to is disclosed
  • Any fee we pay or receive will be disclosed to the customer where it could affect how a recommendation is weighed, consistent with FTC endorsement guidance
  • Their incentives point toward the outcome we want, not toward volume or speed alone
  • They have not promised results they cannot control: approvals, revenue, timelines, introductions not yet secured

Terms and exit

  • Written agreement, even a short one, rather than a handshake
  • Purpose stated in one or two sentences
  • Each side's obligations are specific enough that a missed one is visible
  • Scope and exclusions defined, with a process for changes
  • Customer ownership defined before, during and after the relationship
  • Money defined: trigger, amount, timing, duration, reporting and audit rights
  • Decision rights assigned for pricing, marketing, adding third parties and handling disputes
  • We own our data, lists, notes and anything created for us, and get it back in a usable format
  • Confidentiality covers what each side may say about the other and to whom
  • Fixed initial term with renewal by mutual agreement, not automatic
  • Notice period for ending early stated; cause for immediate termination defined
  • Clauses that survive the end are listed, with time limits where appropriate
  • Transition cooperation after notice is described
  • Agreement reviewed by our business attorney before signing

Communication

  • A standing cadence agreed: how often we meet and in what format
  • A response-time expectation for routine and urgent matters, with urgent defined
  • A shared record of introductions made and received, with outcomes
  • They report back on what happened to introductions we make to them
  • They answered our questions directly during evaluation, including the uncomfortable ones
  • They told us something we did not want to hear, which is evidence they will do so later
  • A ninety-day review is scheduled at signing

Compliance and licensing

  • Any license their activity requires in our state is current, confirmed with the issuing agency rather than with them
  • If the relationship touches lending, insurance, securities, real estate, health care or legal services, counsel has confirmed what licenses and disclosures apply to both sides
  • Referral fees, if any, are permitted in both parties' industries
  • Certificate of insurance provided, with coverage appropriate to the work
  • If they will hold our data or our customers' data, their protection practices are described in writing
  • They understand that an introduction from us is not an endorsement or guarantee, and that the same is true in reverse
  • Nothing in their marketing or proposal makes claims they could not substantiate

General information, not advice

This checklist is general information for business owners. It is not legal, tax, lending or financial advice, and it does not create a client relationship with Nexus Partnership Group LLC. Have a business attorney review any partnership, referral or service agreement before you sign. Confirm licenses with the relevant state agency. Where a relationship touches a regulated field, confirm with counsel and your CPA what rules apply. Nexus is not a law firm, accounting firm, lender, broker or adviser, and an introduction from Nexus is never an endorsement or guarantee.

Sources

Can I use this checklist for vendors as well as partners?

Yes. The groups apply to any outside company you are considering working with closely: a strategic partner, a referral source, a consultant or a service provider. Skip items that do not apply and add any that are specific to your industry.

What if a prospective partner refuses to answer some of these questions?

Treat a refusal as information. Some questions, such as naming specific clients, have legitimate confidentiality limits, and a good partner will explain the limit and offer an alternative. A refusal to confirm legal registration, licensing, insurance or compensation arrangements is a different matter and usually a reason to stop.

Is this checklist legal advice?

No. It is general information to help you organize an evaluation. Have a business attorney review any partnership, referral or service agreement before you sign, and confirm licensing requirements with the relevant state agency, not with the partner.

Related reading

Talk with Nexus about this

If you are evaluating a partner and want a second opinion on the scoring, tell us about the relationship you are considering.